jeff-w-Dy76qbe7gTE-unsplash

Taxing vapes should be handled with care, experts say

Johannesburg – Imposing excise on vapour products in a country like South Africa could prove detrimental, instead encouraging the kind of illicit trade that was seen for contraband cigarettes during the COVID-19 hard lockdown, Vapour Products Association of South Africa (VPASA) has warned.

The warning came from the Vaping Conversations series, hosted by VPASA, by Arshad Abba, a partner at management consultancy Quantum Logik Consulting and the lead on the 2018 Canback study on vaping and its economic impact in South Africa.

Abba was among the high-profile panel of speakers sharing the platform with moderator Dr Delon Human, co-chair of the Africa Harm Reduction Alliance (AHRA), and fellow speaker Professor Donato Raponi, a freelance tax consultant and an honorary professor of European Tax Law at the Ecole Supérieure des Sciences Fiscales in Brussels, Belgium. Raponi has been ranked several times among the 10 most influential people in the world in tax matters by the International Tax Review.

“We also note that the relative price of e-cigarettes is directly related to the price of cigarettes. So when cigarettes are priced significantly higher than e-cigarettes, the market flourishes. And if e-cigarettes are priced too high due to taxes, the market declines,” he said.

Key takeaways from the diginar included a consensus that no excise should be levied on vapour products as it is a harm reduced product similar to that of a mask being worn to prevent contracting COVID-19. However, if excise were to be applied, it should be:

  • Managed within a clear, standalone category after an extensive socio-economic impact assessment has been conducted,
  • Set at a rate that reflects the potentially lower-risk profile of vaping, which has been scientifically proven to be a harm-reduced product,
  • Levied only on nicotine-containing solutions and not on the device, and
  • Should not be linked to nicotine concentration.

“The importance of looking at a risk continuum tax where harm-reduction products are concerned is imperative,” remarked Asanda Gcoyi, CEO of VPASA.

“While the vapour products industry is 100 percent in favour of legislation, we must ensure that conducive environments are put in place for an excise duty to be imposed on an industry.

“It will be of no help to the millions of smokers, or the country’s fiscus,for an excise duty to kill the industry before it has even begun to make an impact in the lives of those looking for less harmful alternatives to combustible cigarettes.”

Sunday World

This article was first published by Sunday World on the 25 November 2020. 

Latest Articles

50th South African school now water-secure thanks to Woolies Water Fund, MySchool MyVillage MyPlanet

03/24/2021

Emafini Primary School in New Brighton, Gqeberha is the 50th school to receive a comprehensive water harvesting system from the Woolies Water Fund, helping them become water secure. The water harvesting system consists of two x 10 000l water tanks, gutters on the roof to channel the rain water into the tanks, a filtration system and large…

Read More

Aiming high: how to make investment choices in the cannabis world

03/24/2021

Picking stocks in the cannabis space can be a daunting task, but what once used to be a very ‘out there’ sector is now whetting the appetite of investors. It all started in 2018, when Canada legalised recreational use, but the UK is becoming an increasingly fertile ground for the sector after the FCA allowed…

Read More

LGBTQ+ real estate forum appoints five board members

03/23/2021

  The networking forum welcomes Sarah Rock, Lucy Smith, Dan Westeley, Ian Pattinson and Scott Parsons to the company board. Sarah Rock is principal associate at global law firm Gowling WLG (UK) LLP, Lucy Smith is a partner at HTA Design LLP, a practice for professionals like architects and urban planners, Dan Westeley is leasing…

Read More

50th South African school now water-secure thanks to Woolies Water Fund, MySchool MyVillage MyPlanet

03/24/2021

Emafini Primary School in New Brighton, Gqeberha is the 50th school to receive a comprehensive water harvesting system from the Woolies Water Fund, helping them become water secure. The water harvesting system consists of two x 10 000l water tanks, gutters on the roof to channel the rain water into the tanks, a filtration system and large…

Read More

Aiming high: how to make investment choices in the cannabis world

03/24/2021

Picking stocks in the cannabis space can be a daunting task, but what once used to be a very ‘out there’ sector is now whetting the appetite of investors. It all started in 2018, when Canada legalised recreational use, but the UK is becoming an increasingly fertile ground for the sector after the FCA allowed…

Read More

LGBTQ+ real estate forum appoints five board members

03/23/2021

  The networking forum welcomes Sarah Rock, Lucy Smith, Dan Westeley, Ian Pattinson and Scott Parsons to the company board. Sarah Rock is principal associate at global law firm Gowling WLG (UK) LLP, Lucy Smith is a partner at HTA Design LLP, a practice for professionals like architects and urban planners, Dan Westeley is leasing…

Read More

Ender’s game: how to game our way to vaccine understanding

03/23/2021

  How digital solutions – including games and animation – can play a critical role in disseminating accurate and effective information about the crucial COVID vaccine. By: Glenn Gillis The global rollout of COVID-19 vaccines is gearing up to be the largest, fastest and most difficult vaccination programme in history. No issue in our time…

Read More